Synthesis:
The readings this week all dealt
with vocabulary instruction. I learned through the readings just how important
vocabulary instruction is for students in all levels of schooling. According to
Hinchman and Thomas, “the words an author uses can cause many middle school
students to stumble as they read conceptually dense subject area material.”
Many texts that adolescents are exposed to in school are informational texts,
which “require students to have a functioning knowledge of many conceptually
loaded terms” (Harmon, Wood, and Medina). This means that no matter the
subject-area, teachers of adolescents should involve vocabulary instruction
into their daily teaching time.
Despite the importance of students’ vocabulary
development, statistics show that the time spent on teaching vocabulary in
schools is not sufficient for many students. According to the Manzo, Manzo, and
Thomas article, “research indicates that the vocabulary level of U.S. college-bound
18-year olds has dropped very sharply in recent years.” A lack of vocabulary
knowledge can affect a student’s academic performance dramatically.
Vocabulary in the text influences
comprehension drastically. A student’s vocabulary knowledge can affect 70-80%
of what students understand from the reading, according to the Hinchman and Thomas text. Many words that appear in the text will be words the reader is already familiar with. These words are tier 1
words (high-frequency words) and tier 2 words, which appear in a variety of
subject areas. The main words that can be troublesome to students are known as
tier 3 words. These vocabulary words are specific to a certain subject area. It can be difficult to determine the meaning of tier 3 words just by using the context clues. These words require direct instruction. This means that the instructor must
educate the students in-depth about not only what the word means, but also how the word is
used. The teacher can also associate the tier 3 words with other words the
student knows to help the student fully comprehend the meaning. There are many
strategies that were discussed in the reading that teachers can use to improve
their vocabulary instruction. These strategies include peer teaching, using
K-W-L charts, and educating students on how roots and morphemes can make analyzing
word meanings an easier task. Also, different technology tools can be
incorporated into instruction to motivate students when studying vocabulary.
Responses:
(Text to Self)
I do not remember my teachers
providing me with in-depth vocabulary instruction in middle school. Sadly, most
of my vocabulary “instruction” memories involve the teachers telling us to
write the definitions of words from the chapter that we were studying. We did
not learn these words in a meaningful context. I wrote down definitions but
never made any connections to other words. I realize now that there are so many
other ways to teach words that would be so much more valuable to students.
(Text to Text)
I wrote a research paper while I
was an undergrad about effective vocabulary instruction for beginning readers.
Although this class and the readings discuss mainly adolescent literacy, I
still made a connection this week to my readings and my paper that I wrote 3
years ago. In my paper, I wrote about strategies that teachers could use to
help their young readers. I mentioned the importance of direct and explicit
instruction, multiple exposures, and small group instruction, along with other
techniques. These methods, when used appropriately in the classroom, were shown
to improve vocabulary knowledge for students in various studies.
(Text to World)
I think the topic of vocabulary
instruction is an important one to discuss. I think more time should be spent on developing vocabulary in schools, especially the vocabulary that is vital to comprehending texts. Each teacher needs to realize that he/she is still a
reading teacher even if the subject is math, science, or history.
In the United States, there is such
a large focus on standardized tests. Teachers have pressure to prepare their
students for these high-stakes tests that show what they have learned during
the year. In the article written by Manzo, Manzo, and Thomas, vocabulary
development is described as “one of the most important things teachers can do
for students cognitively, culturally, and socially and is good preparation for
standardized tests.” There is no excuse for teachers to omit vocabulary instruction due to test prepping.
Questions:
1. How
can I balance tier 3 vocabulary instruction with tier 1 and 2 instruction (for
my struggling readers)?
I think that sometimes
struggling readers can get overlooked when discussing vocabulary instruction.
Of course, it is important to learn content-specific words to understand
subject area text. But for students who have a difficult time with reading,
they may need instruction with more than just the low-frequency words. My goal
is to be a reading specialist so I can help these kiddos learn the reading
techniques and the high-frequency vocabulary they need to know to become
successful readers.
2. How
do I make sure that students truly understand the words that I teach them?
I’m always afraid
that no matter how I explain something, there may still be students who don’t fully
comprehend the material. Especially if the students do not have the prior
knowledge or experience with the word, it can make the explanation difficult.
Thank you all for reading my post!!! I look forward to reading your responses about vocabulary instruction.
Courtney, I have a similar question about teaching vocabulary to my struggling students. I truly believe that my struggling readers are the ones who need more vocabulary expose, compared to my other students, especially since they more than likely lack the skills to figure the meaning of the word on their own. That being said, I worry that teaching tier 3 words could easily discourage and turn those students off from reading even more so than they are.
ReplyDeleteYou second question is great as well. While I believe that authentic instruction so a student can learn vocabulary words is important, I also truly believe that accessing them should be creative and authentic as well. How can we see if our students know the vocabulary words, without shoving a piece of paper and pencil under their nose??
Great post!!
Courtney, my memories of vocabulary in school are also of writing the word and definition. I don't recall any specific activities with them save the inevitable quiz, nor do I recall any in-depth discussion of the terms. I don't have my students do this in class, and I haven't seen many of my co-workers do it often either.
ReplyDeleteI have the same question in regards to struggling readers. It is difficult to incorporate higher-level vocabulary when some of your students struggle with tier 1 words. Will defining the higher-tiered words be sufficient, or do they need more in-depth explanation? Tough question!
I also wonder if the students truly understand the words I teach them. This year I am trying a new strategy. I will have 2-3 challenge words each week that are based off vocabulary from the previous 2 weeks that can easily be incorporated in their writing. Students are encouraged to try to use them in their writings, and they can score extra points for using them correctly in the current week's writing. Perhaps something similar could help you?